My wife and I cannot agree on a fair way to split group dinner checks.

By @liamish · Relationships

When we go out with friends, she thinks we should pay our exact share based on what we ordered. I think we should just split the total bill evenly by the number of people to keep things simple and avoid awkward math at the table.

The full story

My wife and I have this recurring, low-stakes argument every time we go out for a group dinner. It's not a marriage-ender, but it's becoming a genuinely frustrating pattern and I want to solve it. Here's the situation: when the bill comes, my immediate instinct is to take the total, divide it by the number of people, and have everyone throw in that amount. It's fast, it's easy, and it avoids the whole song-and-dance of passing the bill around while everyone squints at their line items. Her perspective is that this is fundamentally unfair. She argues that she often orders a cheaper meal, like a salad or an appetizer, and doesn't drink alcohol, while some of our friends might order multiple expensive cocktails and the most expensive steak on the menu. In her eyes, when we split evenly, we are effectively subsidizing their more expensive tastes. She wants to use a bill-splitting app or a calculator to figure out exactly what each person owes, down to the cent. I see her point logically, but I find the process of doing that at the table to be socially awkward and a bit stingy. It feels like it kills the relaxed, friendly vibe of the dinner. We're all fortunate enough to be able to afford a meal out, and I feel like an extra $5 or $10 here and there is just the social cost of keeping things smooth and avoiding a 10-minute accounting session at the end of the night. It feels like we're auditing our friends. Last weekend, this came to a head. The bill came, I said "let's just split it four ways," and she immediately said, "No, let's figure it out, I only had a soup." It created this really awkward silence. One of our friends looked uncomfortable, while the other one immediately offered to pay for his drinks separately. It just made the whole end of the meal feel transactional and tense. I feel like the social grace of splitting evenly is worth more than the few dollars we'd save, but she feels like she's constantly being taken advantage of. We need a standard policy for this.

How people voted

Readers are split: “Both Messy” leads with 40% — 42 votes and 5 comments so far.

What people are saying

Keep reading

Vote now on BeSoForeal