My wife and I accidentally started a competitive baked potato rivalry and now it's out of control.
By @yarawelp · Food
It started as a joke to see who could make a better baked potato for dinner one night. Now, we're three months in, there are spreadsheets involved, and our friends are being asked to be official judges. I think we need to call a truce but she wants to formalize the rules.
The full story
This all began about three months ago on a random Tuesday. My wife and I were both tired from work and neither of us wanted to cook a complicated meal, so we landed on baked potatoes. I made a comment, completely joking, that my potato technique was superior because I use a specific method to get the skin crispy. She disagreed, and the 'Great Potato-Off' was born. For the first month, it was fun and low-stakes. We'd try different toppings, different kinds of potatoes, different baking methods (foil vs. no foil, salting techniques, etc.). We'd have them maybe once a week and declare a winner ourselves. But then she created a spreadsheet. The spreadsheet tracks scores on a 10-point scale across five categories: Skin Crispiness, Interior Fluffiness, Topping Synergy, Structural Integrity, and Overall Presentation. She even added conditional formatting. That's when things escalated. She started sourcing artisanal cheeses and bacon from a specialty butcher. I responded by growing my own chives in a window box. Last week, for 'International Week,' she presented a potato with tikka masala toppings. I countered with a poutine-inspired potato using hand-cut fries and real cheese curds. It's getting expensive and honestly, I'm running out of ideas. I am not as passionate about this as she is. The real problem is that she has now drafted a 'Formal Rules and Regulations' document. It's four pages long. It includes sections on blind judging, official scoring rubrics, and a schedule for the rest of the year. She wants to invite our friends over for a formal tasting event next month to be the judges. I suggested we just stop and go back to eating potatoes like normal people, and she said I was 'running from the competition' and 'afraid to admit defeat.' I'm not afraid, I'm just tired of thinking about potatoes this much. I need a logical way to de-escalate this situation without admitting she's the 'Supreme Potato Champion,' because her proposed rules state the winner gets that title for life.
How people voted
- Totally Cooked — 25% (7 votes)
- It’s Complicated — 36% (10 votes)
- You’re Fine — 39% (11 votes)
Readers are split: “You’re Fine” leads with 39% — 28 votes and 5 comments so far.
What people are saying
@daniee — You can't just 'accidentally' start a spreadsheet, my dude. Let's be real, you were into it for a while.
@remylol — Secretly replace her artisanal cheese with Velveeta right before the judging. See how 'synergistic' that is.
@sasha — lmaoooo
@brynnforsure — This is the most married-couple thing I have ever read.
@quinnyk — A man should know how to cook a potato, end of story.
Keep reading
- My boyfriend's new 'culinary' hobby is just making adult Lunchables.
- I ordered a single fork to my apartment on doordash.
- My girlfriend keeps eating my takeout leftovers without asking.
- Unpopular opinion: putting ketchup on a good steak should be illegal.
- My roommate thinks using my leftover takeout as an ingredient is not stealing.