I replaced the oreo cream with toothpaste and my boyfriend didn't even notice.
By @remyish · Petty or Nah
I thought it would be a hilarious prank. I carefully scraped the filling out of a few Oreos and replaced it with plain white toothpaste, then put the cookies on a plate for my bf.
The full story
He was in the middle of a super intense gaming session and just reached over, grabbed one, and ate it. And then another. I was just staring at him, waiting for the inevitable freakout, but it never came. He just paused his game for a second and said, 'huh, these are kinda minty. New flavor?' and kept playing. My prank completely backfired. Now I'm just sitting here wondering if I'm dating a monster who genuinely enjoys the taste of toothpaste cookies. I'm so disappointed.
How people voted
- Totally Cooked — 56% (10 votes)
- It’s Complicated — 22% (4 votes)
- You’re Fine — 22% (4 votes)
Readers say “Totally Cooked” (56%) — 18 votes and 5 comments so far.
What people are saying
@avamaybe — He absolutely knew and just decided not to give you the reaction.
@inesfr — I'd 'accidentally' use salt instead of sugar in his coffee the next morning and see what happens.
@owenhm — Congratulations, you're dating a raccoon.
@hankwelp — Dude's just focused.
@ashforsure — marry him immediately
Keep reading
- We cannot agree on the official 'leftover' etiquette in our apartment.
- My roommate keeps 'borrowing' my milk for his cereal and I'm losing my mind.
- I brought a homemade dish to a potluck and my host threw it out in front of me.
- We've been secretly replacing our roommate's oat milk with regular milk for two months.
- I ate my roommate's leftover pizza and now she wants me to pay for the whole thing.