Someone opted out of the cabin grocery bill after we already bought everything.
By @fayekk · Petty or Nah
After agreeing to split our cabin trip food, a friend showed up with her own meal prep and deducted the brisket and dairy from her Venmo cut. The organizer bought ingredients based on eight people, but she claims she shouldn't pay for what she won't touch.
The full story
We have had this cabin booked for a late fall weekend trip since July. There are eight of us going. Four weeks ago, our friend who volunteered to organize the grocery haul made a massive spreadsheet for every meal, including Saturday night dinner: 12-hour slow-cooked brisket, homemade macaroni and cheese, cornbread, and apple crisp. We all enthusiastically approved it. Cut to Thursday night. We all pull up to the rental, unpack, and sit down to settle the group ledger. The grocery bill is $740 total, roughly $92 per person. Out of nowhere, one friend chimes in and announces she brought her own pre-made lentil stew in Tupperware and won't be eating the brisket, so she refuses to pay any portion of the meat or dairy budget. She calculated her share down to $28 for 'shared paper towels, firewood, and cooking oil.' Here is the thing: she never mentioned a dietary shift or opting out in the group chat beforehand. The organizer bought prime cut beef specifically because eight portions were requested. When we gently pointed out that ingredients were purchased based on her headcount, she said we could just 'eat more brisket' and that forcing her to fund an expensive meat dish she won't touch is unethical. The mood in the house instantly soured. It's not about the $64 difference; it's about shifting your grocery costs onto everyone else after the food is already bought.
How people voted
- Bad Move — 40% (52 votes)
- Needs Context — 41% (53 votes)
- Reasonable — 19% (25 votes)
Readers are split: “Needs Context” leads with 41% — 130 votes and 5 comments so far.
What people are saying
@reesekay — lmaooo
@judemaybe — This is purely passive-aggressive resentment over group dynamics disguised as an ethical stance.
@danatbh — love that she discovered her morals the exact second the bill arrived.
@gabeactually — I would put a slice of brisket on her pillow every single night of that trip.
@willawelp — Oh honey, trips like this really show you who people are, just try to enjoy the beautiful fall weather and don't let it ruin your weekend.
Keep reading
- My friend claimed leftovers left at his apartment immediately become community property.
- A dad in our carpool Venmo requested another parent for a string cheese.
- I threw away my coworker's pizza because he stole my lasagna yesterday.
- I will never understand people who get weird about leftovers.
- At what point does being 'thrifty' just become rude?