My friend claimed leftovers left at his apartment immediately become community property.
By @finnyk · Petty or Nah
After paying for half a pizza during football and leaving four slices labeled with my name, the host let his brother eat them and refused to pay me back. He insists any food left in his house belongs to whoever is awake in the living room.
The full story
Here is the saga. My friend hosts Sunday football at his place every single weekend, which sounds amazing until you realize how the kitchen economy operates. We all bring our own six-packs or snacks, but he orders large pizzas for whoever wants to pitch in. Standard stuff. Two weeks ago, I paid $25 into the pool, ate two slices, and left four full slices in the box labeled with my name in Sharpie because I had to leave early. I told him straight up, 'Leave those in the fridge, I will grab them tomorrow when I come by to return your drill.' I arrive Monday afternoon. The box is gone. He looks me in the eye and says his younger brother stopped by Sunday night around midnight, saw the pizza, and crushed it. When I looked annoyed, he laughed and said the statute of limitations on leftover party food expires the second you cross the threshold of his front door. He claims that once someone leaves food at a host's house, it automatically converts into 'community property for whoever is currently breathing in the apartment.' Fast forward to yesterday. We do the order again. This time he leaves his entire half-eaten gourmet Italian sub wrapped in foil on the counter while he runs out to pick up his girlfriend from the train station. I was still hungry. I didn't eat it, but I genuinely stood there debating eating half of it just to establish judicial precedent. Instead, I texted him that he owed me $12 for the slices his brother ate, and he reacted like I handed him a summons for court. The rest of the guys in our group chat are split right down the middle. Some say you never track pennies over food among buddies, while the other half says food theft under your own host roof is basically high treason. Need suggestions on how to handle this without making every Sunday awkward.
How people voted
- Totally Cooked — 44% (7 votes)
- It’s Complicated — 25% (4 votes)
- You’re Fine — 31% (5 votes)
Readers say “Totally Cooked” (44%) — 16 votes and 3 comments so far.
What people are saying
@nicotbh — He lacks basic respect for you and this is going to bleed into everything else if you let it slide.
@pialol — Honey you handled that so much better than most would have, just bring your own snacks next week so you don't have to stress!
@gabeee — Soft.
Keep reading
- A dad in our carpool Venmo requested another parent for a string cheese.
- I threw away my coworker's pizza because he stole my lasagna yesterday.
- I will never understand people who get weird about leftovers.
- At what point does being 'thrifty' just become rude?
- I thought joining the PTO meant helping out, not getting roped into a mascot turf war.