I tried to show my kids that 80s mixtapes were better than Spotify playlists and it ended in total disaster.
By @daniok2 · Unpopular Opinion
My kids think just dragging songs into a list is the same as spending hours waiting for the radio to play the perfect song. I told them a playlist has no soul, so I set out to make a real anniversary mixtape for my wife to prove it.
The full story
We were in the car the other day and my son (20) was the DJ, tapping away on his phone, building a playlist on the fly. I made a comment about how in my day, we had to work for our music. We had mixtapes. The blank C-90 cassette was a canvas, and you were the artist. He and my daughter (18) just gave me the 'Okay, dad' look. They don’t get it. They can't possibly understand the thrill of waiting by the radio, finger poised over the RECORD+PLAY buttons, hoping the DJ would shut up before the guitar solo started. The agony of a song getting cut off. The art of arranging the tracks so Side A flowed perfectly into Side B. So with my anniversary coming up, I decided I wasn't just going to tell them, I was going to show them. I dug out my old Sony boombox from the garage, a beautiful silver beast that weighs more than our dog. Then I found my old shoebox of tapes and, thankfully, one sealed TDK 90-minute blank. This was it. Operation Anniversary Mix 2026 was a go. The first problem: the radio sucks now. It’s all the same 20 songs, or it’s a talk show. And the commercials! My god. I spent a whole Saturday trying to catch just a few of the songs my wife and I loved, and my recordings were littered with announcers and jingles. Defeated, I decided to 'cheat' and play songs from Spotify on my laptop and record them onto the tape through a cable. It felt dirty, but I was desperate. After another few hours of tinkering and getting the levels right, I had it. A masterpiece. All our songs, in chronological order of our relationship. I was so proud. I called the kids and my wife into the living room for the grand presentation. I popped the tape in, hit play, and… nothing. Just a weird whirring sound. I ejected the tape, and my heart sank. The boombox had unspooled about a foot of the tape into its guts. It was completely eaten. My masterpiece was a crinkled black ribbon. The kids absolutely lost it, howling with laughter. Even my wife couldn't hold back a giggle. I spent a whole weekend on a project their phone could do in five minutes, and I failed spectacularly. They're never going to let me live this down, but I swear, the five songs that *almost* worked sounded warmer than any playlist.
How people voted
- Valid Take — 13% (5 votes)
- I’m Torn — 34% (13 votes)
- Bad Take — 53% (20 votes)
Readers say “Bad Take” (53%) — 38 votes and 5 comments so far.
What people are saying
@owenlately — the kids are wrong you should find a working tape deck and try again
@danikindof — crying
@hollylol — The real problem here is a 20 year old still living at home.
@jaredhm — L boomer.
@hankyy — I refuse to believe the radio is that bad, you just wanted to complain.
Keep reading
- I will never understand the obsession with making everything 'smart'.
- It's become impossible to make a simple plan and have it stick.
- Blocking someone online is a neutral act and we need to stop treating it like a declaration of war.
- Unpopular opinion: The office is not your family and we don't need to celebrate everything.
- I am officially done with 'family style' dinners.