I created a shared document to track my team's coffee order etiquette and now HR wants to talk to me.
By @kirakay · Work
We have a rotating system for who gets the morning coffee. Some people are consistently getting it wrong – wrong sizes, wrong milks, wrong everything. I made a spreadsheet to log the 'infractions' as a joke, but my manager didn't find it funny.
The full story
I work in a pretty collaborative office, and our team has this informal tradition of a daily coffee run. The 'rule' is that if you're the one going, you pick up the tab, and it all evens out over time. The problem is, it doesn't even out. Not even close. There are a few serial offenders who either never volunteer, or when they do, they mess up the orders so consistently it feels intentional. We're talking whole milk for the lactose-intolerant project manager, a large black coffee for the person who only drinks iced vanilla lattes, forgetting orders entirely. It became a running joke, but also a genuine source of morning frustration. My work friend and I would complain about it constantly. So, as a bit of a data-viz gag, I created a a place nearby Sheet titled 'The Coffee Accountability Ledger.' I made columns for 'Order Accuracy,' 'Timeliness,' 'Ratio of Runs Made vs. Coffees Consumed,' and even a 'Notes' section for egregious errors (e.g., 'spilled half of CEO's americano in the elevator'). I shared it with my work friend, and we'd laugh about it privately. I thought it was just a funny, petty way to vent about a minor office annoyance. Somehow, the link got out. I think my friend sent it to another person on our team, who sent it to another, and this morning I walked in to find it projected on the main conference room screen during a sales meeting. My manager pulled me aside and said that while he 'appreciates the initiative,' it's created a 'culture of mistrust' and that several team members have complained to HR. Now I have a meeting with HR and my manager this afternoon to discuss 'appropriate workplace communication.' I feel like this has been blown way out of proportion, but I’m also starting to wonder if I crossed a line.
How people voted
- Side A — 33% (15 votes)
- Both — 41% (19 votes)
- Side B — 26% (12 votes)
Readers are split: “Both” leads with 41% — 46 votes and 5 comments so far.
What people are saying
@didieven — This is a classic case of weaponized incompetence from your coworkers.
@onlymondays — Soft.
@oookayyy — nah this is incredible do not apologize for your art
@stellaok — This sounds like a productive use of company time.
@ashyy — I feel like making a spreadsheet is a little more than a 'joke' in a professional setting.
Keep reading
- I took a pay cut so my coworker could keep his job.
- At what point does a coworker's 'health kick' become a workplace disturbance?
- My coworkers made a group chat without me to complain about me.
- I accidentally found out my manager uses a different fake laugh for every executive.
- Every time I go to the office coffee bar someone tries to pay for my drink.