Our fan subreddit can't agree on what counts as a spoiler for a prequel series.

By @laneish · Internet

I'm a moderator for a big TV show subreddit, and we're deadlocked. Half the community thinks it's impossible to spoil a story that finished years ago, while the other half wants to protect new viewers who are starting with the prequel.

The full story

I help moderate a subreddit for a popular fantasy series that ended about five years ago, let's call it 'Aethelgard's Fall'. It's been a pretty straightforward job until now. The studio just released a new prequel series, 'The First Kingdom,' set 200 years before the original story, and it's created a fundamental disagreement about our spoiler policy. The core of the problem is this: the original books and show obviously reveal the ultimate fate of many of the characters, families, and kingdoms that are the main focus of the new prequel. As a result, our mod team and the community are completely split down the middle. Group A believes that any discussion of events from the original series should be considered a major spoiler. Their argument is that the prequel is attracting a lot of new fans who have never seen 'Aethelgard's Fall'. For these new viewers, learning that a certain character's entire lineage will be brutally extinguished in the future is a massive spoiler that ruins the tension. They want us to enforce strict spoiler tags on any mention of events from the original show to preserve that experience for them. Group B argues that this is fundamentally absurd. The original material has been out for over a decade. It's established history within the universe. They see it as being equivalent to watching a historical drama about a figure whose fate is well known; the tension comes from the 'how,' not the 'what.' They feel that the entire point of a prequel is to add context to a known outcome. They're arguing that tagging everything from the original show would make discussion threads clunky and unreadable, and that the responsibility should be on new viewers to manage their own experience. The mod team is at a total impasse. We need to implement a clear, consistent policy that will last for the entire run of the new show, but every proposed solution alienates half of the user base. I need to present a logical path forward. What's the most fair and practical rule to implement here? Is one side clearly more correct than the other from a community management perspective?

How people voted

Readers say “I’m Torn” (44%) — 18 votes and 5 comments so far.

What people are saying

Keep reading

Vote now on BeSoForeal